Donatello's

Discover Donatello's Pizza in Niagara Falls, NY, offering delicious NY-style pizza, wings, subs, fish fry, chicken fingers, wraps, and beef on weck. Perfect for tourists and locals alike! Call +1 716-282-2069.

Welcome to Donatello's

Experience the finest dining

Donatello's
Donatello's
Donatello's
Donatello's

Donatello's stands proudly at 466 3rd St, Niagara Falls, NY. This local favorite serves a delicious array of pizza, subs, wings, and more. Whether you're a tourist exploring the wonders of Niagara Falls or a local craving comfort food, Donatello's offers a welcoming atmosphere for everyone.

It’s the perfect spot to enjoy a hearty meal after a day of sightseeing or simply to catch up with friends.

The restaurant buzzes with energy during peak hours but maintains a relaxed charm even at its busiest moments. With a menu accommodating various tastes— from NY-style pizza to their famed fish fry—Donatello's truly shines in the local dining scene. Grab a seat and indulge in a slice of the town's vibrant culture through its food.

Donatello's is more than just a pizza place; it features a diverse menu designed to satisfy any craving. The restaurant specializes in fresh baked pizzas, offering classic flavors and unique combinations like Chicken Finger Pizza and All Veggie Pizza.

For those looking for a lighter bite, the selection of salads and wraps provides tasty alternatives. The famous Beef on Weck and the assortment of subs cater to hearty appetites, making everything from quick lunches to leisurely dinners enjoyable.

The bustling ambiance paired with friendly service adds to the dining experience. Regulars and newcomers alike appreciate the family-oriented environment, ensuring everyone feels at home.

Additionally, Donatello's proudly participates in community events, frequently catering local functions and supporting schools in the area.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

466 3rd St, Niagara Falls, NY 14301, United States

Phone

+1 716-282-2069

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Donatello's
Donatello's
Donatello's
Donatello's

The story of Donatello's Pizza begins with a passion for great food and community. Nestled in the heart of Niagara Falls, this gem has become a beloved part of the local culinary landscape. Its approach combines tradition and innovation, ensuring every dish bursts with flavor and authenticity. Family recipes passed down through generations showcase the essence of Italian-American cuisine, emphasizing quality ingredients and careful preparation.

At Donatello's, the menu is extensive, featuring nearly 100 items crafted to cater to all preferences. Grab a classic slice, dive into a specialty pie, or try the well-loved wings that have locals talking. The wraps, ranging from Chicken Fajita to Antipasto, provide a quick fix for those on the go without sacrificing taste.

The restaurant operates under the motto of serving the community, offering generous portions at reasonable prices. Friday nights often see families filling the booths, especially during the bustling dinner rush. A blend of flavors reveals the distinct local character, harmonizing the vitality of Niagara's tourism with the warmth of hometown dining.

Donatello's also features an inviting bar area where visitors can unwind with a drink while enjoying a meal. The rotating selection of craft beers and wines allows a pleasant finish to any dining experience. With a commitment to quality and a dedication to the community, Donatello's stands as a home away from home for both locals and visitors alike.

Donatello's

Donatello's showcases an inviting exterior with a warm, rustic charm that draws people in. Nestled among other vibrant shops and eateries on 3rd St, the restaurant boasts a cozy patio area ideal for al fresco dining during pleasant weather. The outdoor seating provides a perfect vantage point to people-watch while enjoying a slice or two.

Inside, the decor reflects a blend of classic Italian motifs and contemporary touches, giving the restaurant a welcoming vibe. Dim lighting and colorful artwork contribute to a relaxing dining atmosphere, making it suitable for both romantic evenings and family gatherings.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-7 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-7 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • SaturdayClosed

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

We wanted pizza on our last night and found this local spot. Waiting for our food we could tell it has a lot of regulars. We live in Florida where pizza sucks, and we are from IL so we love our Chicago pizza, but THIS pizza was AMAZING! You can tell that the ingredients are fresh. The crust is light and crispy even though it's thicker. I'm kind of bummed we waited to try it on our last night, I would have gone again! We also got wings which were fresh and huge! They had a good crisp on them and the sauce was great!

S
Stefanie J.

Best wings and pizza we've ever had! Just arrived today from MS and wanted to try a local pizza place. We haven't stopped talking about how delicious it was. And also great friendly service! Thank y'all!!

E
Emily B.

The best pizza place in Niagara Falls. If you want something real and authentic go here. They made us feel at home. This place isn't just open during the tourist busy season. It is a family owned place that will take care of you with great service and amazing food!

B
Bryan S.

We're glad we decided to check this place out. It's a nice mom and pop restaurant that was close to where we were and saw the good ratings. Well, we have to say this place did not disappoint! Their dough and ingredients are made fresh and you can definitely taste it. Some pizza doughs in other places are inconsistent with their texture, but when we cut into their pizza, it seeme like a good texture-- consistent all around. Unsure if they serve the thin crust as an option, but I like how their dough wasn't "doughy" or too thin. Their customer service was great also! They have that "back in the day" old school treatment where you can sit down, eat, and pay when you're done. Their cookies were delicious too! They are very close to a few of the hotels (like the Seneca Hotel) and very close to the Niagra Falls.

J
Jane D.

Went in last night for pizza and it was amazing. Service was wonderful. This was our first time we live about 3 hours away and will definitely come back next time we visit the area.

E
Emily K.

I ordered the buffalo chicken finger salad as carryout and it was delicious! Everything in the salad was very fresh and it was fully loaded with buffalo chicken and vegetables. Staff was friendly and service was fast.

L
Laura